Scarcity. How it surprisingly doomed a legendary brand.

Now, we all know how brands leverage the feeling of scarcity to sell their products faster.

“Limited Time Offer”

“Offer open till stocks last”

“Clearance Sale”

“Black Friday Sale”

“Exclusive Dhanteras Offer”

Not just that, many brands like Apple exploit the psychology of scarcity to make people queue up all night for their new phone launches.

But do you know there was a famous brand in US that got doomed due to this same psychology of scarcity.

In 1985, one of the top companies in the world began a historic blunder that Time magazine called the Marketing fiasco of the decade.

The name of the company – Coca Cola.

After years of researching on a new “better tasting” formula, on April 23, the company decided to pull their traditional formula of coke off the market. They replaced it with New Coke. But the company failed to predict the sheer frustration and fury its action would create. Right across the length and breadth of America, tens of thousands of Coke lovers rose up to revile the taste of New Coke and demand the return of their beloved old Coke back.

Their was even a society that got created – Old Coca Cola Drinkers of America – a widespread group of people who worked tirelessly to get the traditional formula back on the market by using any means necessary – civil, judicial, legislative…

The protests were of a level that made Coca Cola kill the New Coke and reinstate the old Coke.

What caused this outrage?

Even though blind taste tests clearly pointed to the new flavour as the hands down winner, the company failed to take into account something important. The taste tests were done with both flavours being made available to the participants. But when the Coke drinkers realised that the drink they grew up with will no longer be available, it created a psyche of scarcity, leading to an uprising, not unlike the bubbles of a well shaken coke bottle.

6 thoughts on “Scarcity. How it surprisingly doomed a legendary brand.

  1. This episode in Coca Cola’s history reminds me of what happened with Maggi noodles in India. This ever popular brand of ramen noodles was banned by Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) in June 2015 for five months for allegedly containing lead beyond permissible limits.

    Some may have thought that the health safety related adverse findings & ensuing negative media coverage would spell the end for Maggi which was the market leader in its category, by far. In the months during the ban, sales of competing brands shot up.

    However a few generations of consumers with nostalgic memories of growing up snacking on Maggi, were not to forget their favourite noodles that quickly. As soon as the five month ban was over, Maggi sales were back with a vengeance. Consumers even posted online about their glee on getting Maggi back and how they had missed it during the ban. Not only did the brand survive its ban, it thrived after its fans
    were faced with its sudden scarcity.

    Like

  2. Sometimes strange becomes true, familiar false. In a way it is a case of synergistic loop. Success follows success.
    Brilliant. Very well written.

    Like

Leave a reply to Monica Gupta Cancel reply